Using Arbitration To Resolve Transfer Pricing Disputes And The Impact Of The Oecds Unified Approach Proposal

In this article, the author considers the use of alternative forms of dispute resolution to resolve tax treaty disputes, focusing on the potential benefits of and obstacles to using mandatory binding arbitration to resolve transfer pricing disputes, including those that may arise under the OECD's Unified Approach for allocating profits in the digital economy.

This book addresses the complexity, valuation and administrative nuances, and cultural impacts of resolving this significant cross-border issue when tax disputes arise. In recent years, transfer pricing has become in financial terms the most important tax issue faced by multinational companies and tax authorities worldwide. In times of economic downturn, as experienced in recent years, when tax authorities are challenged for revenue, the handling of these issues requires great care, skill, creativity and a true awareness of the ramifications confronting each tax jurisdiction. This book sets out in detail not only the general laws in each tax jurisdiction impacted by the multinational companies' transfer pricing practices, but also the ancillary concerns of how the issue is interpreted locally as well as related to the OECD Guidelines; the varied approaches to administrative resolution of these issues, including specific alternative dispute resolution mechanisms and the effective uses of advance pricing agreements; correlative adjustment procedures in the event of transfer pricing adjustments; cross-border exchange of information concerns; and how to proceed to litigation if all else fails administratively. It is here that the book delves into the specific procedures for litigation in each country which must be evaluated as part of the overall strategy for controversy resolution. Unfortunately, today litigation is on the rise in numerous jurisdictions and the presumption of an administrative resolution is no longer correct. An additional feature of this book is how practical anecdotes are intertwined into the analysis to give the reader a sense of pragmatism for these issues. To this point, there are the various case studies which highlight the technicalities of the local rules, customs, and practices.

Via a global analysis of more than 180 transfer pricing cases from 20 representative jurisdictions, Resolving Transfer Pricing Disputes explains how the law on transfer pricing operates in practice and examines how disputes between taxpayers and tax administrations are dealt with around the world. It has been designed to be an essential complement to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, which focus on transfer pricing issues but do not refer to specific transfer pricing disputes. All of the transfer pricing cases discussed in the book are linked to the relevant paragraphs of the OECD Guidelines by means of a 'Golden Bridge', namely a table listing the cases according to the paragraphs of the Guidelines to which they refer. It therefore provides examples of the application of the Arm's Length Principle in many settings on all continents.

Arbitration: the solution to tackle cross-border tax disputes From the increasing integration of the world economy and the lack of rules to govern the taxation of multinational enterprises to cross-border tax disputes: arbitration is one potential solution. Arbitration is not a new development in the international tax arena, but it has not yet been widely implemented in practice. In the last few years, the concept of arbitration in tax matters was revived, mainly following the OECD/G20 BEPS Project, as well as the EU Action Plan on Corporate Taxation. Now arbitration is expected to play a more significant role and enhance the existing framework of cross-border tax dispute resolution. „OECD Arbitration in Tax Treaty Law” constitutes a comprehensive compendium on international tax arbitration and provides in-depth analysis of all relevant aspects of the topic. The introductory chapters provide background information on tax arbitration and comparisons with other areas of law. The book also takes stock of the recent developments in this area within the OECD, the EU, the UN and the United States. It addresses the main concerns that have been raised with regard to arbitration, and compares and contrasts the design of various arbitration clauses. It also considers potential future developments. This compendium on international tax arbitration shows one way how to tackle the rising tide of cross-border tax disputes.

Analysis of both the concluded and the proposed dispute resolution methods. The relationship between the current developments in tax treaty law and the more general trends of modern dispute resolution in public international law is investigated. Concludes with a summary and evaluation of several alternative methods of dispute resolution in recent treaty practice.

This report addresses the practical administration of transfer pricing programmes by tax administrations.

Fiscally transparent entities and tax treaty eligibility Shefali Goradia Triangular cases – the neglected problem in tax treaty law Michael Lang Can tax treaty entitlement provisions for hybrid entities be refined? Dhruv Sanghavi Non-discrimination provisions in tax treaties Ajay Vohra Two to tango: a dance of substance and form Bijal Ajinkya Deconstructing Principal Purpose Test under Article 7 of MLI Mukesh Butani Preventing treaty abuse in the context of multilateral instrument Dinesh Kanabar and Saurabh Shah Taxation of digital economy – the journey, India and across the world Daksha Baxi Digitalisation of the economy: Our perspective on the OECD's Unified Approach Vikram Chand Reflections on the 2019 OECD proposal on Pillar One Guglielmo Maisto Implementation of BEPS and Amendments to Section 9 Radhakishan Rawal Public international law, object and purpose, MLI, BEPS and the OECD Model Tax Convention Clive M. Baxter Tax laws through a constitutional prism Arvind P. Datar Tax policy as a tool to enable impact investment and improve CSR targeting Meyyappan Nagappan and Nehal Binani Tax system design - an analysis of some design choices made by the Indian Income Tax Act, 1961 Shreya Rao Through the looking glass: resolving tax disputes by arbitration under a bilateral investment treaty H. David Rosenbloom

Consists of the first three chapters of the 2011 edition which have been updated based on information available up to 15 September, 1 August, and 31 July 2014, respectively.

Despite the vast literature on the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations (OECD Guidelines), its status has received little consideration. The image in the literature is that the OECD Guidelines is a significant publication, given the substantial cross-border trade between associated enterprises. In the OECD/G20 BEPS Project, the Final Report on Actions 8-10, published in 2015, revised the OECD Guidelines as part of the sweeping measures to counter aggressive tax avoidance by certain multinational enterprises (MNEs), such as Google LLC, Facebook Inc. and Apple Inc. BEPS Actions 8-10, inter alia, revised the guidance on intangibles and cost contribution arrangements to prevent profits from intangibles being allocated to low-tax jurisdictions. As anticipated, the OECD has reported that transfer pricing disputes are rising. In particular, BEPS Action 14, on dispute resolution, requires tax treaties to include article 9(2) of the OECD Model Tax Convention, on corresponding transfer pricing adjustments, in tax treaties. Moreover, BEPS Action 14 (element 1.1 of the minimum standard) requires that access to the mutual agreement procedure be available for transfer pricing cases in tax treaties and that countries implement the resulting mutual agreements. As a minimum standard, members of the Inclusive Framework are obliged to implement this measure, which further elevates the status of the OECD Guidelines, as resulting disputes will be resolved on the basis of the principles in the OECD Guidelines. The membership of the Inclusive Framework exceeds 135 countries. As there is a dearth of transfer pricing case law, the consequence is that courts have only established limited jurisprudence on the topic. One Australian transfer pricing case concluded that the OECD Guidelines had no formal status in treaty interpretation. It is asserted in this article that the OECD Guidelines is part of the Commentary accompanying the OECD Model Convention on Income and on Capital. Even so, it is argued that treaty countries should not only use the OECD Guidelines as a guidance document in their domestic rules, but expressly state in their tax treaties that the OECD Guidelines are to be used for the interpretation of the associated enterprises article. In addition, the treaty statement should specify whether the static or ambulatory approach should be applied.This article asserts that the best way forward is for the OECD to illuminate the status of the OECD Guidelines by including a clear statement in the Commentary on the intrinsic character of the OECD Guidelines and expressly identify which parts of the OECD Guidelines form part of the Commentary, adapting the approach taken in the Commentary on the business profits article incorporating the 2010 Report on the Attribution of Permanent Establishments.

Transfer pricing is an area of tax law that has significantly expanded over the last decades. With the globalisation of business activities, the threat of international double taxation, and the need for States to monitor transfer prices to avoid the illegitimate erosion of their tax base, transfer pricing has become a key question for multinational enterprises and tax administrations. The book provides a general overview on the fundamentals of transfer pricing from an OECD perspective. The book also illustrates the fundamentals of transfer pricing with concrete examples based on the structures often used by multinational enterprises when entering into cross-border intercompany transactions. This book is primarily addressed to students reading international tax courses, but may also be of use to tax professionals in matters pertaining to transfer pricing.